Friday, April 25, 2014

Sketchbooks: Good Teaching Practice

We’d like to introduce a couple of key core values about the Sketchbooks in Schools approach:

The teacher shouldn’t make marks (of any kind) directly in a pupils sketchbook!

There’s been lots of debate since we started this project about how we can protect the sketchbook as a place for pupils to call their own, and at the same time balance the potential need (when used within school) for a sketchbook to be seen by a teacher, or even to be assessed (this is a prickly area and we will create resources to kick start the debate very soon).

When sketchbooks are shared by a pupil, with a teacher or the rest of the class, we feel very strongly that we should be respectful of the pupils’ books and their content (and so teach them respect).

Understanding how to nurture sketchbook work is the subject of another module (coming soon). There are two simple ways however which teachers might want to think about introducing as being courteous and non-destructive ways to feedback to pupils about their sketchbook work:

1) Post-it. Use post-its, or paper and paper clips, on sketchbook pages as a way of giving feedback on work, and helping with direction etc.
Post-it note for teacher feedback

2) Invest in one-to-one. Pupils and teachers will find “tutorial” style feedback much more beneficial, although of course it takes more time. But if this kind of feedback is built in to the school day/week it really provides an opportunity to build an understanding of how the child is thinking, and promotes self-directed learning. It also works well in small groups too, so pupils can benefit from each others thought processes.

The teacher should try the activity too!

When pupils see the teacher trying the same activity as them it works for two (at least) reasons:

1) It’s very empowering for the pupils to see the teacher “learning”. It again promotes the idea of self-directed learning, and demonstrates learning as a creative and life long process with exciting outcomes.

2) Through trying the activity for themselves, teachers can benefit from a greater understanding of their own creativity, directly experience and understand more deeply WHY the activity is being undertaken, and actively think towards HOW the activity can be developed.

If you have any comments or suggestions re the above advice please use the comment box below.

“I agree with not writing in the sketchbooks, however does anyone else have a better idea than post it notes? When you’re assessing sketchbooks as part of an art class, these can often go missing – resulting in some young people saying they never recieved it in the first place! Maybe a pro forma that could be stuck in the back and numbered pages? Does seem a bit long winded though….ideas welcomed!” Guerilla Embroidery

“I did a project with 17 year olds as part of a team/leadership building activity week for Skills Development Scotland, where we filled in a simply made sketchbook with drawings of what the students found difficult, important and what made them proud. It turned out to be a great record of achievement, a lovely souvenir, and one they all seemed to cherish. Research is continuing.” Jenny Soep

“We used sketch books in school last year and they worked quite well, i don’t agree with writing in the children’s books either. Towards the end of the year i was working with groups of children and we talked about what content they had in their journal so i could ensure they had gathered the info they needed and guide them in their next steps to their learning. It was also a good opportunity for the children to share designs, good pieces of work and their ides with myself and others.” Rachel Little

“I would suggest: that sketchbooks shouldn’t be split into “school work” and “homework”.

I have memories of sketchbooks in my school being given two states – the first: use the front for the work we give you to do, the second: turn your sketchbook upside down and use that end of the sketchbook for any sketching you might want to do at home. The problem I have with this is that it a) seems to imply importance of school work over home”doodle”, and b) that really the sketchbook should be wholly owned by the pupil and all content should come from the pupil, whether its initiated by school or the pupils themselves. Maybe better to encourage separate sketchbooks for different types of activity – but all important…” Paula

“This has really changed the way I look at art within my classroom and also within in the school. As a new subject leader I didn’t really know where to start, but this project has really made me think about how we look at art as a whole.” Sam Franklin

“Another method which I promote to my teachers in West Sussex for giving direction is to use your own sketchbook in class to model or exemplify a point alongside the child. We often use strip sketchbooks [half A5 size]and encourage children who are reluctant to commit to the blank page to work over our own work or alongside it. This provides a useful scaffold / starting point for some children.” Jane Sedgewick

“I agree, a sketchbook must remain personal and intimate to the individual who owns it, therefore, to maintain respect the teacher can give feedback in a manner that is non intrusive and yet supportive. Post-its brilliant approach!” Arlene C Marsh

Copyright AccessArt 2013 www.accessart.org.uk

Create PDF    Send article as PDF   

Comments

6 Responses to “Sketchbooks: Good Teaching Practice”
  1. Whilst I’m not generally a fan of teachers writing in a pupil’s sketchbook, it’s not always a bad thing. I remember going on an art dayschool run by an artist I respected; at one point the artist started to draw in my sketchbook to demonstrate a technique, I drew something to clarify my understanding, then he added something else and it became visual conversation. Some of my later drawings in that sketchbook related back to that event. A thumbnail sketch to demonstrate a technique, perhaps accompanied by a suggestions of which artists can be seen to have used that technique can be a valuable part of the sketchbook, especially if further work arises from it.
    A post-it note that gets lost is useless.
    A sketchbook shows a part of your creative journey and may well show how other have had input in to that journey. It’s a working tool, and being too precious about it defeats its purpose.

  2. Sue Emms says:

    I would like to have more info on making a 2 hour workshop on colour theory an exciting 2 hours and not a boring slog for the student and the teacher. Ideas please. I am teaching adults.

    • Margaret Christison says:

      I teach creativity workshops to adults and this involves fun inner child stuff. How about having coloured envelopes/boxes each with a piece of information about the theory. Each box fits into the colour wheel itself ,each participant reads and shares the bit of information in their box then places their box/envelope into the appropriate place on the wheel. Kinaesthetic learning!
      Also -in addition to the mysterious opening of parcel/envelope- you could put in a sweetie or tiny toy to add to excitement. Good wishes for the workshop.

      Margaret

  3. Benjamin Barker says:

    Jackie,

    I am glad you mentioned the idea of post it notes. I am just launching into sketchbooks with my classes (K-6 in Australia). In setting up an understanding of how open ended and personalized the process aims to be, I think I will ask them to decide is it valuable and useful input I am offering them at any given time. I can put my input onto post it notes and if they choose as the owner of the work, they can protect it by pasting it in. Thanks for prompting what I think might be a good idea…

    • Margaret Christison says:

      I love your option of the student pasting it in if they want to keep it. My only query with post-its is they usually are brightly coloured and may be the brightest thing on the student’s page.A scrap of paper could be more subtle?

Trackbacks

Check out what others are saying about this post...


Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

Optionally add an image (JPEG only)

Copyright © 2014 www.accessart.org.uk. All Rights Reserved. 

s2Member®